Crime & Safety

Police: Tarrytown Tag Sale Goes Horribly Wrong

A woman having a moving out sale in her home will leave town with the bad taste of grand larceny losses.

The unsavory story of a tag sale gone really wrong surfaced in Facebook, where a woman planning on having another sale day told her friends she had to call it off when she realized just how much she had lost.

A Wildey Street resident moving out of town planned to have what was meant to be a tag sale where items get sold for money, not a free-for-all for thieves.

Police have no suspect on who may have stolen numerous valuables, amounting to a grand larceny case with their value, from the open home that anywhere from 65 to 100 people might have entered in the course of the day on August 3.

Police got a call from the woman on August 4 at 9:38 a.m. that in the course of the first few hours of the tag sale she had the day before between the hours of 6:45 a.m. to 5 p.m. she had discovered several items missing:

  • An IBM laptop ($700)
  • and a Virgin cell phone.
She called off the tag sale she was going to continue that day.

On the morning of August 5, she confirmed with police that further items were gone:
  • A string of pearls with matching bracelet,
  • a white gold ring with small diamond,
  • a gold ring with two gold balls
Later that afternoon, she added to this list the loss of:
  • Cash ($550 to $700),
  • Nikon cameras with two lenses,
  • a pair Olympus binoculars,
  • crocodile purse,
  • Tiffany necklace (string of pearls),
  • Tiffany cake plate with cake cutter,
  • gold pocket watch,
  • gold ladies wristwatch,
  • two wide yellow gold wedding bands,
  • platinum engagement ring with sapphire stone and two white diamonds on each side,
  • white gold earrings with small diamond studs,
  • and two yellow gold rings with mother of pearls.
With so many people coming through the house that day, Lt. William Herguth said narrowing it down to a suspect or more is unlikely.

"There's very little information as to what she can provide," he said. 

Herguth hadn't recalled any similar robberies of tag sale items like this "in recent times."

There's a grand larceny case filed due to the extent of the value of the missing goods.

If anyone has information, please contact police detectives at 914.631.5544.


Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.

We’ve removed the ability to reply as we work to make improvements. Learn more here

To request removal of your name from an arrest report, submit these required items to arrestreports@patch.com.