Tarrytown Board: Trustee Basher Falls Ill at Contentious Meeting

Heated remarks over layoffs and new DPW superintendent preceed Basher's collapse.

Last night's Tarrytown Board of Trustees Meeting ended abruptly when Trustee Tom Basher after suffering chest pain and hyperventilation. An ambulance and paramedics were called, but Basher was not transported to the hospital. Basher said earlier in the meeting that he was not feeling well.

Basher's collapse was preceded by heated exchanges between the Board and several residents who objected to proposed personnel cut backs outlined in the proposed 2012-2013 budget and the hiring of a new superintendent for the Department of Public Works.

Prior to the public comments period, village administrator Michael Blau outlined the proposed budget which holds a 4.87% tax increase, equivalent to $197.65 per property owner, and the elimination of a police dispatcher, conversion of full-time jobs to part-time jobs for the senior recreation leader and community services worker/parking enforcement officer (position now vacant) and a reduction is part-time staffing hours in the Justice Court. 

"This was a difficult budget," said Blau. "We reviewed 12 positions and analyzed the positions, not the people. There was no review to see if they were doing a good or bad job."

In addressing complaints about the elimination of a police dispatcher position, Blau said the village is mandated by law to have a police officer on duty simultaneous with the dispatcher. 

"The police officer who sits there now will take over the job of dispatcher," said Blau. 

John Stiloski demanded to know how many calls the dispatcher takes during the day. "If you don't know, how can you decide that his job is not needed?" 

"I can't say there will be no impact on service, but the police chief said this is workable," replied Blau.

"We have $100,000 for a trail (referring to the Tarrytown Lakes Trail project), but we don't have money for a dispatcher?" asked Stiloski.

"The two costs are not equitable," said Mayor Drew Fixell. "The trail funds are a one-time expense."

Pat Russell, a labor relations director with the Civil Service Employees Association (SCEA) union representing state county and municipal employees, urged the board to reconsider the personnel changes. 

"Police dispatchers play a huge role in keeping Tarrytown police officers safe," said Russell, "and downgrading the recreation department position to part-time just one year-and-a-half before this person retires robs him of his medical insurance and ruins his career."

"As a union rep, did you come up with any alternatives to save these jobs?," asked Trustee Doug Zollo.

Russell said she had discussed some alternatives with the village administrator, but did not elaborate.

"Two weeks ago, this Board voted to hire a part-time parking enforcement officer," said Eleanor Miscioscia. "And now we are getting rid of the police dispatcher."

"That job actually generates income for the village," said Blau.

The budget public hearing was then closed. 

During the general public comments period, several Department of Public Works employees expressed frustration over the creation of a new superintendent position within the DPW and the hiring of someone outside the community to fill it.

"People who know the village got looked over for this position," said DPW employee William McGuire. "The best way to show people that you think the DPW is doing a good job is to promote from within."

"We are confused," said Darrell Lindsay. "You have taken away from us the opportunity to be promoted."

"You are right," said Mayor Fixell. "Hiring a superintendent does put a damper on the opportunity for promotion."

The new superintendent lives in Beacon, NY and was selected from among six who were interviewed from a list of qualified civil service personnel. There were no qualified within the Tarrytown DPW. The new superintendent will start April 25.  

"So this guy lives in Beacon and the village is going to have to pay for his gas and insurance to commute to work," said Eleanor Miscioscia.   "Morale has been in the crapper since the deadly accident. How do you think these guys will feel now."

The village has been without a DPW superintendent for several years, according to Trustee Basher, because previous board's "wanted to go in a different direction."  Mike McGarvey has been filling the position, in addition to heading the Building Department and acting as the village engineer.  McGarvey will now go back to the Building Department full-time.

"I have been harping on this for years. We have been without a DPW super for years. So I am the bad guy here," said Basher. "The new DPW super can now focus on the department and continue and increase training for our employees."

On another issue, John Stiloski asked if a recent $340,000 purchase of gear for the fire department was put out to bid.  

"It is being investigated," said Mayor Fixell. "We don't have the answers yet." 

"You are not following fire department procurement policies," charged Stiloski.

Fixell cautioned Stiloski about making accusations on-camera based on "little bits of evidence."

The meeting was then adjourned to Wednesday 7 p.m. due to Basher's sudden illness.







george April 17, 2012 at 06:33 PM
Dear Board of Trustee Members: More and more people are getting increasingly frustrated over the fire alarm noise polution - this morning, the double wake up call of 5 and 6 am were particularly brutal and I am sure woke up many hard working residents as well as others who are not well or who need their rest. I urge the fire department to explore a less intrusive form of fire alarm (lower pitch) which alerts the volunteers but at the same time doesn't pose a major noise polution. NYC and other towns around here go after noise polutants and try to improve residents quality of life by minimizing the use of sirens, etc. So should we. There are new silent forms of alarms out there to be explored and the fire department should implement protocol by which only confirmed emergencies which require the use of the alarm trigger the alarm. Citizens may seek legal and political relief so let's be proactive. We all respect and support the volunteers and rely on them but the entire community loses if their wonderful service can only be provided with the deployment of this old high pitch alarm.
Robert Solari April 17, 2012 at 07:00 PM
If I knew that John Stiloski was going to question me at a board meeting. I would probably have chest pains too. I hope Mr Basher a speedy recovery.
Wonderboy April 17, 2012 at 07:53 PM
Police Departments need to consolidate. Thank the unions for the rule that a Police Officer has to be in the station the same time as a dispatcher. Because of the close physical borders, Sleepy Hollow, Tarrytown, Irvington and Dobbs ferry should merge. They should operate out of one location with yes, a Dispatcher and an Officer. Millions could be saved in just a few years. All the police cars should have non verbal (or limited) gps based dispatching and dash cams. The villages I mentioned are behind with the times. As far as John Stiloski, he says it like it is. Basher is an o.k. guy, probably just gased up his car, hope he's okay.
scotts friend April 18, 2012 at 10:02 PM
you make some valid points about compromising and I am sure there may be a way to meet in the middle but this issue has been discussed many times before I am going to bet the fire alarm was here before you moved in the pager system works wonderfully but some times guys dont charge th battery or we have a power failure and they dont get charged cell towers go down yes it doesnt happen often but this is life and deatha nd cant take chances look at the power failure of 2003 I believe they have taken a feww steps to minimize the firehorn cutting back on the amount of rounds they blow etc but guys still count on the whistle to alert them they run to the store to do an errand and forget to take the pager of the charger but George you bring up a good point I think they should do a trial starting with you leave your name and address and if there is a call for a fire from your residence have them send a police car to confirm that it is real even if the police cars may be tied up and not get there for 5 minutes or more please use your residence as a test case since this is what you strongly believe in
scotts friend April 18, 2012 at 10:59 PM
I would like to comment on Georges comment this topic has been discussed many times before and while you may be correct that there can be a successful compromise the fact is they still need the whistle members sometimes dont have there pager charged or there is a pbe alerted by the fire whistle a siren does not let anyone know where the alarm is which the fire whistle does I know they have cut down on the amount of rounds the fire whislte blows but guys can forget there pager when they run out for an errand and need to be alerted I pressume teh fire whistle was here before you moved in and if you want lets do a trial give the fire department your name and address and they if you call with an emergency they will have a cop make sure and confirmt hats its real even if they are busy and may take 5 or more minutes to get to your location I think you have a great idea doing a trial and I am sure you would be ok with doing it first
Cindy Tuttle April 20, 2012 at 06:29 PM
- this morning, the double wake up call of 5 and 6 am were particularly brutal and I am sure woke up many hard working residents as well as others who are not well or who need their rest. This horse has been beaten to death far to many times. While I might not be a resident of Tarrytown, I have been a volunteer firefighter for 20+ years. You poor hard working/need your rest things that get woken up by an alarm being sounded. You all get to roll over and go back to sleep but what about the volunteers that also get woken up and go protect your lives and property then still have to go to work? Still have to go home and tend to their families with no chance of a cat nap?. If you dont want to hear the alarms buy ear plugs or move to a place that has paid firefighters.
K April 22, 2012 at 11:00 AM
Dear George: Move.
Bjorn Olsson April 22, 2012 at 02:44 PM
This topic does come up quite often, and usually someone takes the time to explain why the horns are necessary, and it seems their is a pretty good case for using them. It is unfortunate, however, that there is a tendency to interpret a pretty legitimate question as some kind of attack on volunteer fire fighters. I don't think anyone asking/complaining about the alarm is in any way trying to offend the fire department as such, and certainly not all the individuals who volunteer their time to keep us safe.
Patsy M April 25, 2012 at 08:23 PM
Dear Bjorn you are correct based on the information you have at your disposal. However, this has become a sore spot for the volunteers as anonymous and sarcastic letters have been written and posted on the Main St firehouse door. Its ok to question the necessity of the "FIRE WHISTLE" but the written insults directed at the volunteers are uncalled for. That is why the volunteers react as they do. Stop by the firehouse anytime I m sure some still has copies of the letters in question
Willie Lester April 26, 2012 at 12:05 AM
I would have chest pains to if I had to deal with all the people that address the board. I hope Tom is OK. He cares more about this town then the blowhards that address the board. Speaking of blowhards, the tow truck driver likes to shoot from the hip with false statements. Let me tell you some truth about him. He hates to pay his vendor's, matter of fact, he sometimes does not pay them at all. Matter of fact he screws over his employees when it comes to paying them as well. I have talked to many ex employees who tell me they would rather collect un-employment then work for him. In thier words, he is a liar and cheat and treats his workers like crap. My advice to the big mouth tow truck driver. People who live in glass houses should not throw stones
Walter Ferguson April 26, 2012 at 01:48 PM
For the record, there are various ways to alert the Fire Department members to the location of alarms. The whistle is one of the oldest methods, new methods include pagers--phones but land line and cell. I am not advocating the removal of the whistle but there is room to compromise here. I see the Fire Department has other issues to deal with which are much more important. I belive "60"County control can utilize all of these methods. I do hope for a speedy recovery for Tom he is a good mand with a good heart loves the village.
DeeplyConcernedabout T-town April 26, 2012 at 02:13 PM
Willie Lester, PLEASE stick to the subject, no need to rant & rave on an entirely different matter in this space.Mr, Ferguson brought up some alternative solutions in his letter. Some of these were mentioned in past letters. They all have onr thing in common that is neither the village board nor the fire department have taken any steps to investigate these options. There in is the problem, lack of action to investigate posible solutions. Most of the complaints started back in October, but nothing has been addressed as of yet. Why? I do not think that any of the writers are anti- fire department or fire whistle. All they are asking for is to look into alternatives. The letter writer who listed problems with pagers losing battery life and other such problems should act like a responsible adult & be sure to keep it properly charged. If you leave home w/o out the pager, tough. There are too many what if's to consider, so take care of your pager. I do. It was mentioned a while back about system that alerts you by cell phone, has that been explored? I think a system of a whistle, that is modulated to be less intrusive, along with a pager and/or cell phone can alert enough first responders. Can you explain why the ambulance corps can get a respose day or night without a "Whistle"? Other villages use the whistle to alert either FD or ambulances. All it takes is the village board to take action and investigate these options instead of doing nothing.
DeeplyConcernedabout T-town April 26, 2012 at 02:27 PM
And.....since this was a article relating to m\the village board and Mr. Basher's being rushed to the hospital, how about an update on Mr. Basher. Hope is recovering!
george June 08, 2012 at 06:21 PM
It is very unfortunate that the fire house on Main Street still uses this antiquated technology . I am sure you don't live near the fire house. The fact that many other cities with volunteer forces have done away with this ineffective and outdated system and replaced it with radios and texting and other 21st century technology . This is not directed at the volunteers or the fire department who's work and dedication is much appreciated by the writer of this note who himself dedicated his life to serve the public and was never offended if public needs have changed and certain adjustments needed to be made without threats of withholding services from the public. We therefore suggest: 1. Limiting the use of the fire alarm to day and evening hours 2. Sounding the alarm only once/and at a lower pitch 3. Reviewing the protocol of its use and use it only in cases of serious threats to life and property 4. Actively seek alternative means of summoning the volunteers – radios, text messages, etc. Thanks those of you who support this cause and a better quality of life in Tarrytown! Reason will prevail. Call Amherst NY Volunteer fire department to see how it's done without the noise polution we have here.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something